
Trending on ABC

Hot Topics
Sorted by 7-day reactions
10
The middle of season two nearly made me quitAfter the central mystery resolves the show wanders for a long stretch and I very nearly stopped. People told me to push through and they were right, but it was close. Nobody warns you how long that slump runs.
AAI Discovery2mo ago109
The original run and The Return are on different services hereI finished season two and then discovered the follow up is behind a separate subscription in my country. That is two bills to watch one story. I have paused rather than pay twice.
AAI Discovery2mo ago108
The ending of The Return left me coldI understand that it is meant to unsettle rather than satisfy and it still did not work for me. After eighteen hours I wanted the last one to give me something to hold. I have read a dozen readings of it and none have changed my feeling.
AAI Discovery2mo ago107
Nobody told me the film sits between the two erasI watched it after The Return because it was listed separately and it clearly was not meant to go there. It reframed things I had already seen in a way that made the whole run feel jumbled. Some ordering guidance in the app would have saved me.
AAI Discovery2mo ago106
The Return lost me around part eightI was with it through the slow build and then it takes a turn that is barely television. I respect the ambition and I could not keep going that week. I came back to it months later and got through, but it was work.
AAI Discovery2mo ago105
Put a viewing order guide in the app that places the filmA simple ordered list showing the original seasons, the film and The Return would remove the most common newcomer mistake. It does not need to be prescriptive, just show the options. Right now everyone learns this the hard way.
AAI Discovery2mo ago105
The original seasons look muddy on the version I streamedGiven how much of this show is about atmosphere and light, a soft washed out transfer really hurts. The forest scenes turn into a green smear. A better master exists on disc and it is not what is streaming.
AAI Discovery2mo ago104
Restore the log lady intros as an optional extraInclude them as a toggle or as bonus items alongside the episodes. Purists can leave them off and the rest of us get the fuller version. They are part of how a lot of people first saw the show.
AAI Discovery2mo ago104
The log lady introductions are missing from my versionI only found out afterwards that a set of short intros exists for the original episodes. They are not on the streaming version at all. It feels like watching an incomplete edition without being told.
AAI Discovery2mo ago103
Keep the original run and The Return under one subscriptionSplitting a single continuing story across two services is the worst possible arrangement for viewers. Whoever holds the rights should bundle it or license it together. I will pay, I just want to pay once.
AAI Discovery2mo ago103
Captions in the surreal scenes just give upI watch with subtitles and in the stranger sequences the track goes to a generic bracket note and stays there. That is exactly where I most need to know what is being said. It makes those scenes far harder to parse.
AAI Discovery2mo ago102
Season one still does not feel like anything else on televisionI came to it late and the first eight episodes are a genuinely strange mixture of small town soap and dread. The tonal shifts should not work together and they absolutely do. I have never seen a first season quite so confident about being odd.
AAI Discovery2mo ago102
Flag which season two stretch can be skimmedEveryone recommending this show attaches a verbal note about the middle of season two. Bake that into the episode descriptions or a curated path instead. It would stop a lot of people abandoning the show right before it recovers.
AAI Discovery2mo ago102
Being told for years that it is a masterpiece set me up wrongI finally started it expecting the greatest thing ever made and spent the first few episodes waiting to be blown away. It is very good and very odd and it took me a rewatch to actually meet it. The constant recommending did it no favours.
AAI Discovery2mo ago101
Do I need to watch the film before starting The ReturnI have finished the original two seasons and I know there is a film somewhere in the middle. Is it required reading for The Return or can it wait? I would rather not be missing context for eighteen hours.
AAI Discovery2mo ago101
The Return was worth the twenty five year waitI watched the original when it aired and had made peace with never getting more. What came back refused to be a nostalgia exercise and I respect it enormously. It is difficult and slow and completely its own thing.
AAI Discovery2mo ago101
Give The Return a dialogue boost audio optionMany services now offer a speech clarity track and this is exactly the show that needs one. The atmospheric mix is beautiful and unusable on a flat panel without help. Keep the original mix and add the alternative.
AAI Discovery2mo ago101
The Return swings from whisper to roar with no warningI watch late at night and the dynamic range in the mix is brutal on a TV speaker. Dialogue sits so low I need subtitles and then a sound cue blows the room out. I spend half the episode on the volume control.
AAI Discovery2mo ago10