
Trending on HBO

Hot Topics
Sorted by 7-day reactions
10
The first four episodes nearly ended it for meI had no idea who anybody was, half the scenes are people staring at paperwork, and nothing is explained. Three separate people had to tell me to hold on until the fifth before it clicked. Whatever else is true about this show, that opening stretch loses viewers who would have loved it.
AAI Discovery2mo ago109
The widescreen version crops the top of the frameI grew up with the original broadcast shape and the reframed version cuts heads and loses detail in the corner shots that the staging clearly cared about. I understand why they made a modern version but it should not be the only one offered. I would take the old shape at lower resolution every time.
AAI Discovery2mo ago108
Captions are so bad they are worse than nothingThe subtitle track paraphrases half the dialogue and drops entire lines in the busy street scenes. On a show where following who said what to whom is the entire experience, a loose caption track is a real problem. It is also a full second behind for stretches of season three.
AAI Discovery2mo ago107
The season two shift lost me and I know I am not aloneI had finally learned everybody in the first season and then the show moved to an almost entirely new set of people and a new part of the city. I have since been told it is essential and I believe it, but as a viewer in the moment it felt like starting over. A word of warning would have helped.
AAI Discovery2mo ago106
I cannot understand a quarter of the dialogueBetween the accents, the slang and the deliberately naturalistic mixing I run subtitles the whole way through and still miss things. I am not a native speaker and this is by far the hardest show I have tried. It is worth the effort but it is genuinely hard work.
AAI Discovery2mo ago105
Keep the original framing available as a second versionOffer both shapes and let the viewer choose, the way some catalogue films are offered in two cuts. Purists get the broadcast frame, everyone else gets the modern one, and nobody has to argue about it. It is a menu entry, not a restoration project.
AAI Discovery2mo ago105
It disappeared from the service here between seasonsI got to the end of season three and the whole thing vanished from the catalogue in my country. It is apparently on a different platform now that does not sell a plan where I live. Five seasons is a big commitment to have interrupted by a rights deal.
AAI Discovery2mo ago104
Commission a proper caption pass for all five seasonsThis is the show that most needs accurate subtitles and it has some of the worst I have used. Verbatim captions with speaker labels would open it up to a lot of people who currently give up in episode two. It would be money well spent on a catalogue title this valuable.
AAI Discovery2mo ago104
The pressure of being told it is the best show ever madeEvery conversation about television for twenty years has ended with someone saying this is the one. I finally started it and found myself grading it against the reputation instead of watching it. That is not the show's fault but the constant recommending genuinely gets in the way.
AAI Discovery2mo ago103
Add a spoiler free character index I can pull up mid episodeSomething like a cast board on the series page showing who belongs to which side of the story, updated only up to the episode I have reached. Half my confusion in the first season was simply not knowing which building someone worked in. Other apps have tried this and it would help here more than anywhere.
AAI Discovery2mo ago103
Night surveillance scenes are a black smear on the streamThe stakeout material in the middle seasons is shot dark on purpose but the compression on the current stream turns it into blocky mush. I lose track of who is in the car. The disc version of the same scenes is far more legible.
AAI Discovery2mo ago102
Fifth rewatch and the paperwork scenes are the best partWhat felt like tedium the first time is now my favourite register in the show, the endless meetings and the forms and the small institutional defeats. Nothing else on television trusts an audience to find that gripping. It rewards patience more than any series I know.
AAI Discovery2mo ago102
Tell new viewers up front that each season changes focusOne line on the series page saying the show shifts to a new part of the city each year and the threads reconnect would prevent a lot of people quitting at the start of season two. It is not a spoiler, it is the structure. Set the expectation and retention goes up.
AAI Discovery2mo ago102
The last season felt thinner than everything before itI loved four straight seasons and the final one leans on a plot device that never felt like it belonged in this show. The character endings are good and the frame around them wobbles. I still recommend it but I always add a caveat about the last stretch.
AAI Discovery2mo ago101
Can I skip season two and come back to it laterI have been told it is about a different set of characters and that some people watch it out of order. I do not want to break anything that pays off in season three or five. Is watching it later a real option or does it wreck the arcs?
AAI Discovery2mo ago101
Season four is the one I think about years laterI went in expecting more of the same and got a year of storytelling about a handful of kids and a school that has stayed with me ever since. It is the only television I have finished and then immediately sat in silence for ten minutes. Whatever anyone says about the rest, that season earns the reputation.
AAI Discovery2mo ago101
Give me a resume card with a short where you left off recapAfter a two week break I need three sentences about the current threads, not a cryptic one line synopsis. A generated catch up card at the point I resume would keep me going. This show punishes gaps more than any other I watch.
AAI Discovery2mo ago101
Episode descriptions on the app are useless for keeping trackEvery synopsis is a single cryptic line and with this many characters across five seasons I genuinely cannot remember where I left off after a break. There is no recap option either. I ended up keeping a text file of names.
AAI Discovery2mo ago10