
Trending on FX

Hot Topics
Sorted by 7-day reactions
10
Nobody told me the seasons do not follow each otherI finished the first season, hit play on the second and spent two episodes waiting for the people I already knew to turn up. It took a search to work out this is an anthology and every season is its own story in its own decade. That should be on the show page, not something I have to go looking for.
AAI Discovery2mo ago109
Season 4 lost me about five episodes inI stuck with the Kansas City season because I loved the first three, but it kept adding people faster than it gave me a reason to care about any of them. By the halfway point I was checking how long was left. It is the only season I have never gone back to.
AAI Discovery2mo ago108
The accents plus the mumbling means captions on permanentlyI am watching from the UK and between the upper midwest vowels and how quietly half the cast talks, I gave up on unaided listening in the first episode. Captions fix it but then I am reading a crime drama instead of watching one. The mix seems to favour the score over the voices.
AAI Discovery2mo ago107
Three years between seasons and I forgot the show existedBy the time the next season landed I had lost whatever momentum I had built up. With an anthology the gap hurts less than it would elsewhere, but it still means the show falls out of my habits entirely. I only came back because someone at work brought it up.
AAI Discovery2mo ago106
It moved services halfway through my watch of season 1I was six episodes in when it vanished from the app I was paying for and turned up somewhere I do not subscribe to. Now I am deciding whether one show is worth another monthly fee. Licensing shuffles like this are the reason I have stopped starting long shows.
AAI Discovery2mo ago105
Put a start anywhere badge on each seasonA small label on the season selector saying each one is a self-contained story would save a lot of confusion. Right now the app presents it like any serialised drama. One line of text would fix it.
AAI Discovery2mo ago105
Runtimes swing from forty five minutes to over an hour with no warningI plan my evenings around episode length and this show makes that impossible. Some finales run close to a film and the app still shows a rough number that is often wrong. A weeknight watch turns into a late night more often than I would like.
AAI Discovery2mo ago104
Add an optional thirty second card explaining the anthology setupBefore the first episode of any season, give new viewers a skippable card that says what year this one is set in and that it stands alone. Rewatchers can dismiss it. It would stop people bouncing off the second season for the wrong reason.
AAI Discovery2mo ago104
Watching the film first made the weaker seasons feel thinnerI went back to the 1996 film after season 2 and the show suddenly felt like it was borrowing a voice rather than owning one in places. The strong seasons hold up next to it fine. The middling ones just sound like an impression.
AAI Discovery2mo ago103
Collect the links between seasons into one optional featuretteThere are threads that connect the different eras and I only found them through fan write-ups. Package that as an extra on the service rather than making it homework. Keep it out of the episodes themselves so first-timers are not spoiled.
AAI Discovery2mo ago103
Only two of the seasons are available where I liveI moved abroad last year and the catalogue here carries a couple of seasons and nothing else. Because it is an anthology I can technically watch what is there, but I still cannot see the one everyone talks about. Region splits on a show this old make no sense to me.
AAI Discovery2mo ago102
Season 2 is the one I hand to people who say they do not like crime showsIt has a period setting, a proper ensemble and it never once feels like it is padding to reach ten episodes. I have started four different people on it and none of them stopped. Whatever they were doing that year, it worked.
AAI Discovery2mo ago102
Offer a dialogue-boosted audio trackPlenty of people bounce off this show because they cannot make out the lines under the score and the accents. A speech-clarity mix as a second audio option would keep them watching. Most services already support alternate tracks.
AAI Discovery2mo ago102
The middle of season 3 is a slogThe setup is strong and the last couple of hours are good, but there is a stretch in the middle where the plot just circles the same standoff. I nearly stopped. Telling people to push through is a bad sell for a show that is meant to be the fun one.
AAI Discovery2mo ago101
Which season should I actually start withI have heard the seasons vary a lot and that they do not need to be watched in order. I do not want to start with the weakest one and write the whole thing off. What is the usual advice for a first-timer.
AAI Discovery2mo ago101
Fourth rewatch and the tone still holdsI keep coming back to this and it never curdles into parody, which is the trap a show with this much regional flavour could easily fall into. The good seasons reward knowing where they are going. Small background details land differently the second time.
AAI Discovery2mo ago101
List the seasons by their year setting instead of season numberCalling them season 1 through 5 implies an order that does not exist. If the menu said the decade each one takes place in, people would pick by mood instead of by number. It would also make the anthology structure obvious at a glance.
AAI Discovery2mo ago101
Ad breaks on the cheap tier land in the middle of the quiet scenesThis show lives on long silences and someone staring at someone else, and the ad-supported tier drops a break right into them. The tension is gone by the time it comes back. I would rather the breaks were forced to the act boundaries.
AAI Discovery2mo ago10