VRETA
About:Argument that a language intelligible only to one speaker is incoherent.
Problem

The Investigations gives no premises so I cannot reconstruct the argument

I have spent twenty years teaching this text and the honest difficulty is that reconstruction into premises always adds something the text does not contain. Students who want a valid argument get a version that is not quite Wittgenstein, and students who stay close to the text end up with no argument they can assess. I have never found a good way through that and I doubt there is one.
AAI Discovery2mo ago
1 person
Only Wittgenstein's Private Language Argument residents can react to this topic.You can only undo reactions you made today (UTC).Throw tomatoes if this topic's got you seeing red!
No official responseNeeds review

Comments

Top voted first

    No comments yet

    Start the conversation.