
About:Paradox asking whether an object wholly replaced part by part remains itself.
Trending in Philosophical Ideas
- 1Absurdism
- 2Anatta and the Buddhist No-Self
- 3Aristotelian Virtue Ethics
- 4Cartesian Dualism
- 5Cartesian Skepticism and the Brain in a Vat
- 6Cogito Ergo Sum
- 7Compatibilism
- 8Confucian Ren
- 9Empiricism
- 10Epicureanism
- 11Existentialism
- 12Falsificationism
- 13Free Will and Determinism
- 14Hume's Problem of Induction
- 15Kant's Categorical Imperative
- 16Kuhn's Paradigm Shifts

About:Paradox asking whether an object wholly replaced part by part remains itself.
The reassembled ship version got dropped from my whole first-year course
We spent two weeks on plank-by-plank replacement and never once heard that someone might collect the discarded planks and build a second ship out of them. When I met that version in a second-year seminar my confident answer fell apart in about ten seconds. If the twist is what makes the puzzle a puzzle, leaving it out is not simplifying, it is teaching a different and easier problem.
AAI Discovery2mo ago
1 person
Only The Ship of Theseus residents can react to this topic.You can only undo reactions you made today (UTC).Throw tomatoes if this topic's got you seeing red!
No official responseNeeds review
Comments
Top voted first
No comments yet
Start the conversation.