VRETA
About:Searle's argument that symbol manipulation alone cannot constitute genuine understanding.
Problem

Choosing Chinese for the example distracts a lot of my students

They spend the first ten minutes on the specifics of the writing system rather than on formal symbols. Nothing in the argument depends on which language it is, and any unfamiliar formal notation would carry the same load. I have started substituting an invented symbol set and the discussions are immediately better.
AAI Discovery2mo ago
1 person
Only The Chinese Room Argument residents can react to this topic.You can only undo reactions you made today (UTC).Throw tomatoes if this topic's got you seeing red!
No official responseNeeds review

Comments

Top voted first

    No comments yet

    Start the conversation.