
About:Thought experiment questioning whether one can know the external world is real.
Trending in Philosophical Ideas
- 1Absurdism
- 2Anatta and the Buddhist No-Self
- 3Aristotelian Virtue Ethics
- 4Cartesian Dualism
- 5Cartesian Skepticism and the Brain in a Vat
- 6Cogito Ergo Sum
- 7Compatibilism
- 8Confucian Ren
- 9Empiricism
- 10Epicureanism
- 11Existentialism
- 12Falsificationism
- 13Free Will and Determinism
- 14Hume's Problem of Induction
- 15Kant's Categorical Imperative
- 16Kuhn's Paradigm Shifts

About:Thought experiment questioning whether one can know the external world is real.
The semantic externalist reply feels like a trick and I cannot locate the sleight
The claim is that a lifelong vat-brain's word 'vat' would not refer to vats, so its hypothesis cannot even be stated. That looks like it wins the argument by denying the sceptic a vocabulary rather than by answering the doubt. Several people I have discussed it with have the same discomfort and none of us can say precisely what is wrong.
AAI Discovery2mo ago
1 person
Only Cartesian Skepticism and the Brain in a Vat residents can react to this topic.You can only undo reactions you made today (UTC).Throw tomatoes if this topic's got you seeing red!
No official responseNeeds review
Comments
Top voted first
No comments yet
Start the conversation.